What to Know About BMI Requirements for Surrogates

At every stage of the surrogacy journey, the overall well being of a surrogate is essential to the success of the pregnancy. One factor that can catch intended parents or surrogate candidates off guard is that most fertility clinics include a body mass index (BMI) requirement as part of the screening process. It can seem like a technical detail, but a potential surrogate’s BMI can be a major stumbling block. In some cases, candidates who are otherwise qualified may try to meet the requirement through fast or restrictive diets in too short of a timeframe. While well-intentioned, these efforts to lose weight too quickly can be risky. Creating a careful plan toward healthier habits can lead to better, long-term outcomes when it comes to being medically approved as a gestational surrogate.

Why BMI Matters in the Surrogacy Process

In gestational surrogacy, BMI is one of several health indicators used by IVF clinics to assess a candidate’s readiness and likelihood for a safe and successful pregnancy. It’s important to note that BMI is an imperfect measure that doesn’t account for differences in muscle mass or body composition.¹ Still,BMI is a screening tool that can be helpful when considered alongside other aspects of a surrogate’s health. Fertility clinics rely on established guidelines to help identify candidates with the highest likelihood of successful implantation and healthy pregnancy outcomes.

Most reputable clinics follow recommendations from the American Society for Reproductive Medicine (ASRM), which typically place the ideal surrogate BMI between 19 and 32. This range reflects data showing higher success rates with embryo transfer and fewer pregnancy complications. When a surrogate’s BMI falls outside this range, it may lead to more transfer attempts or an increased risk of medical challenges that can lengthen the timeline for intended parents.

Beyond implantation, BMI also correlates with certain pregnancy risks. Higher BMI ranges are associated with an increased likelihood of gestational diabetes, preeclampsia (a form of high blood pressure that develops during pregnancy), and cesarean delivery. Very low BMIs carry different concerns, including nutritional deficiencies that may interfere with fetal growth. For intended parents, these health factors directly influence the likelihood of a smoother journey with fewer medical interventions.²

The Hidden Risk: Fast Weight Loss to Meet the Cutoff

When potential surrogates learn about BMI requirements, some may attempt to lose weight quickly to qualify for the program or agency. This well-intentioned effort to help intended parents can actually create significant complications that impact the entire surrogacy journey. Rapid weight loss through restrictive diets or intensive exercise regimens may help a candidate temporarily meet the BMI threshold for initial approval, but these approaches rarely lead to sustainable results. In several cases, a surrogate candidate will meet the BMI requirement at the time of records pre-approval on paper, but be over or under the BMI requirement at the time of in-person medical screening. This can cause significant delays in a surrogacy journey or, in some cases, break a surrogate-intended parent match entirely. For this reason, we recommend longer-term, sustainable habit changes when it comes to meeting the BMI requirement for a surrogacy journey.

The surrogacy process involves multiple medical evaluation steps over time. In several cases, a surrogate candidate might receive pre-approval based on self-reported measurements or a weigh-in at a physician’s office, only to face disqualification months later during the in-person medical screening if the weight has increased or decreased outside the BMI range requirement. This scenario creates disappointment and unexpected delays for everyone involved, particularly when matches have already been made with intended parents. What begins as an attempt to qualify for the program can ultimately extend the timeline for building someone’s family. In some cases, this scenario can break a surrogate-intended parent match entirely. For this reason, we recommend longer-term, sustainable habit changes when it comes to meeting the BMI requirement for a surrogacy journey.

Rapid weight changes can also affect reproductive health, adding another layer of concern. Research shows that crash dieting can disrupt hormonal balance, potentially affecting uterine lining development and implantation rates. This translates to a lower chance of successful embryo transfer on the first attempt. Additionally, the physical stress of yo-yo dieting can compromise overall health, potentially introducing new medical concerns that weren’t present during initial screenings.³

A Balanced Perspective: Understanding Weight and Health in Surrogacy

The medical focus on BMI in surrogacy exists alongside growing recognition that health can look different across a range of body types. The Health at Every Size (HAES) health framework offers insights that complement traditional screening practices by emphasizing sustainable, health-promoting behaviors rather than weight alone. While fertility clinics follow established guidelines to maximize success rates, many surrogacy professionals recognize that long-term wellness and weight stability may be stronger indicators of positive outcomes than any single number on the scale. Key considerations in this broader approach include:

Consistent behaviors: Regular physical activity, nutritional eating habits, and other positive health practices often indicate a surrogate candidate’s commitment to wellbeing during pregnancy.
Weight stability: A candidate who maintains consistent habits and stable weight over time typically presents fewer risks than someone who has recently made dramatic changes to qualify for the program.
Pregnancy history: A history of healthy pregnancies without complications often predicts future success better than BMI alone, especially when the candidate’s weight has remained relatively stable.
Sustainable habits: Candidates who approach health through gradual, consistent practices rather than quick fixes are more likely to maintain their wellbeing throughout the demanding surrogacy process.
Psychological wellbeing: A positive, balanced approach to eating and body image contributes to reduced stress and better outcomes throughout the pregnancy journey.

How CFC Approaches BMI in Surrogate Screening

At Creative Family Connections, we recognize that BMI is just one aspect of a potential surrogate’s overall health profile. Our screening process takes a more comprehensive approach, looking at the complete picture of a candidate’s physical wellbeing and health history. While we work within established IVF clinic guidelines for BMI, we also consider factors like previous successful pregnancies, stable weight history, and consistent health patterns that may be better predictors of surrogacy success. For example, we have advocated in the past for unique surrogate candidates who do not meet the BMI requirement, but engage in extensive weight training.

When evaluating surrogate candidates, our team looks carefully at weight stability over time rather than just the current number. This approach helps intended parents avoid the disappointment of a promising match falling through during medical screening or facing delays due to weight changes that emerge later in the process.

Creative Family Connections Is There to Support You

Understanding how BMI fits into the surrogacy process can help intended parents approach matching with greater clarity and realistic expectations. At Creative Family Connections, we guide intended parents through every stage of the journey with compassion, transparency, and attention to the factors that support long-term success. Our experienced team works to identify surrogate candidates whose health profiles reflect stability and readiness for a journey, helping to reduce delays and build strong, sustainable matches. Contact us today to learn more about our screening process and how we can support your family-building goals.

Sources: